The Early Church and Peter's Primacy

Letter V, from Pope Hilarius to Leontius, Bishop of Arles

Synopsis: Hilarius announces his accession to the Apostolic See to Leontius, grounding the announcement in the reverence owed to the blessed Apostle Peter and to his See, and asking Leontius to circulate the news to all the bishops of the province.

Hilarus, bishop, to his most beloved brother Leontius.

How much reverence — in the Spirit of God, who indwells the priests subject to Him — is owed to the blessed Apostle Peter and to his See, I judge to be known to all who hold the incorrupt guardianship of paternal traditions. Since therefore We wish Our brothers to share Our joy in the beginnings of Our ordination, We judged it fitting to communicate to Your Holiness the works that the divine favor has shown toward Us — first, so that you yourself may rejoice with the mutual affection We always show one another, with the Lord’s help; and second, so that through the disposition of your brotherhood it may be made known to all the brothers and fellow priests throughout the whole province that the right hand of the Lord has deigned to visit Our humility and has entrusted to Us the governance of the Apostolic See — not by Our merit, but by the most abundant largess of His grace.

Therefore, dearest brother, deign to share with all the brothers what We have disclosed to Your Holiness in this letter, as We have said — so that as they make supplication to Our Lord Jesus Christ, they may join the vows of their prayers to Ours, benefiting the universal Church even as they share the joys of our exultation. May God keep you safe, dearest brother.

Given on the eighth day before the Kalends of February, in the consulship of our lord Severus Augustus.

Source/Reference

Notes / Historical Commentary

Letter V is an encyclical — one of a number of identical letters Hilarius dispatched after his accession to announce his elevation to the Apostolic See. The one preserved here is addressed to Leontius of Arles; others of identical form would have gone to the leading bishops of every province. Such encyclicals are the formal means by which a new pope announced his accession to the universal Church and requested the prayers of his fellow bishops. The form is conventional; what is worth the reader’s attention is the theological framing Hilarius chose to place at the opening.

The very first sentence, before any mention of Hilarius’s own elevation, establishes the reverence owed to Peter and to his See as the settled premise of the Catholic tradition. The phrasing is careful: the reverence is not proposed or defended — it is “known to all who hold the incorrupt guardianship of paternal traditions.” This is not a new claim being advanced but the ecclesiological ground on which everything else in the letter (and in Hilarius’s pontificate) rests. The reader should notice that Peter and his See are treated as a single object of reverence — beato Petro apostolo et sedi ipsius. The same construction appears throughout Leo’s correspondence: Peter is present in his See, and the See’s authority is Peter’s continuing authority.

The specific office Hilarius names as his own is apostolicae sedis regimen — “the governance of the Apostolic See.” The word regimen is the language of rule, of active governance. This is not an honorific description; it is the self-designation of the office Hilarius now holds. And the scope of that office is named in the letter’s closing purpose clause: the prayers of the Gallic bishops are to profit the universal Church. The reader may compare Leo’s parallel language in Letter V (to the Illyrian metropolitans), where the Roman bishop’s sollicitudo is described as owed to all the Churches. Hilarius is using the same theological vocabulary for the same claim: the office he has received is universal in scope, and its governance is not provincial or regional but reaches to the whole Church. That this claim appears in the very first letter of Hilarius’s pontificate — in its opening sentence, before any other business — shows that it is the foundational premise of everything that follows.

The Early Church and Peter's Primacy