The Early Church and Peter's Primacy

Letter XCII, from Pope Leo to Bishop Julian of Cos

Synopsis: Leo commands Julian to join his care and counsel with the legates sent to the general council at Nicaea, acting throughout with the authority of Leo’s command, since Julian possesses greater local knowledge of Eastern affairs than the legates themselves.

Leo, bishop, to Julian, Bishop of Cos.

Leo Commands Julian to Join His Care and Counsel With the Legates at the General Council, Acting With the Authority of the Papal Command

What We should command of your devoted spirit, you have recognized many times — for many prior instances have given Us cause to presume upon it. Wherefore, since at the will of the most Christian emperor a priestly synod is to be held in the city of Nicaea, that every clamor of scandal may be removed, We necessarily enjoin upon your brotherhood what is of benefit to the whole Church: that you join your care and action with our brothers and fellow bishops Paschasinus and Lucentius, and our brothers and fellow presbyters Bonifacius and Basilius, whom We command to go to the said assembly in Our stead — joining your care and action with theirs in all things, using the authority of Our command, since We know that you have greater knowledge of all matters transacted there than Our legates do: so that by uniting your care and counsel with theirs they may not err in any part, but all things may come to fruition, with God’s aid, that you shall judge fitting for faith and peace.

Dated the sixth day before the Kalends of July, in the consulship of Adelfius, most illustrious man.

Source/Reference

Notes / Historical Commentary

Letter XCII is brief but belongs to the most consequential moment in the Leo corpus: the final pre-Chalcedon packet by which Leo commissioned his legates and oriented the approaching council. It is the second letter Leo wrote to Julian of Cos on this occasion — Letter XCI, also dated June 26, 451, covers the same ground in slightly different terms. The recurrence reflects Julian’s unique role: he was Leo’s permanent personal representative in Constantinople, a man of exceptional usefulness precisely because, as Leo notes, he possesses greater local knowledge of Eastern affairs than any Roman legate dispatched from outside could. XCII is accordingly not a letter of introduction but a formal commission of authority.

The structural logic of the letter appears in a single dense phrase. Vice nostra… ire præcipimus — “We command them to go in Our stead” — restates the vicariate formula that governs all of Leo’s pre-Chalcedon delegations: the legates go as Leo’s personal substitutes, and their acts are his acts. Auctoritate nostræ præceptionis usurus — “using the authority of Our command” — names what the vicariate formula implies. Julian does not act at the council on his own authority as bishop of Cos; he acts under Leo’s authority, which he carries as a commission. The reader will note how authority and knowledge flow in opposite directions in this arrangement: knowledge of local affairs comes from the East, but the authority under which all participants operate comes from Rome. Leo has structured the council so that the combination of both produces what he himself would supply if present in person.

This letter should be read alongside Letter XCIII, Leo’s direct address to the synod, where the same structure is stated at greater theological depth: Leo declares himself present in his vicars, presiding over the council through them. XCII and XCIII together form the two-register commission — the personal instruction to Julian and the formal address to the assembled bishops — that Leo sent as his credential to Chalcedon.

The Early Church and Peter's Primacy