The Early Church and Peter's Primacy

Letter CXLVIII, from Pope Leo to Emperor Leo

Synopsis: Leo rejoices that the emperor has shown himself a guardian of the Council of Chalcedon — having learned this through the report of Anatolius of Constantinople, whom Leo had directed to keep him informed — and urges that the tranquility of the Church be preserved and the stubborn opposition of the heretics suppressed by imperial power.

Leo, bishop of Rome, to Leo, ever Augustus.

Chapter I: Leo Gives Thanks for the Emperor’s Defense of Chalcedon, Learned Through the Report of Anatolius

Although I have recently directed two letters to your clemency — one of which was to fulfill the duty of greeting, the other to make supplication on behalf of the state of the Church — nevertheless, most glorious emperor, the occasion which God’s providence has offered makes it fitting to return to both. Following therefore that confidence which, by the inspiration of God, you have shown toward the universal Church — establishing before anyone’s petitions what was most to be sought by all — we do not cease to give thanks and to bless the providence of God in the fervor of your faith, who, as I have learned from the account of my brother and fellow-bishop Anatolius, with holy and Catholic spirit, has led you to withstand the impudence of the heretics to such a degree that you have professed yourselves to be the guardians of the peace of the whole world through the Council of Chalcedon.

Chapter II: Leo Urges That the Tranquility of the Church Be Preserved and Heretical Opposition Suppressed by Imperial Power

Since this has been most wholesomely determined according to the judgment of your faith, with how much greater diligence must it be maintained for the benefit of the universal Church, that the tranquility of the Christian faith may also profit your empire, and that heretical wickedness may not glory in any part of its scheming. The stubborn and treacherous opposition of that wickedness immediately subsides when it is restrained by imperial power.

Given on the Kalends of September, in the consulship of Constantinus and Rufus, most distinguished men.

Source/Reference

Notes / Historical Commentary

Letter CXLVIII is dated September 1, 457 — approximately seven weeks after the coordinated three-letter campaign of July 11 (Letters CXLV, CXLVI, CXLVII). It belongs to the same Alexandrian crisis cluster but represents a different moment: the initial campaign has been dispatched, Anatolius has reported back on the emperor’s favorable posture, and Leo now writes again to the emperor to reinforce and press the case further. To read this letter in isolation is to miss its place in a sequence that Leo himself is directing.

The chain of command running through this cluster is worth tracing explicitly. In Letter CXLVI, Leo directed Anatolius to press the emperor on the preservation of Chalcedon and to keep Leo informed by frequent letters. Anatolius complied — his report is what Leo is now acting upon. Leo receives Anatolius’s intelligence, evaluates the emperor’s disposition as favorable, and writes again to the emperor to consolidate and deepen that disposition. The Archbishop of Constantinople is not an independent actor managing eastern affairs; he is an instrument of Roman oversight, gathering and relaying information that Rome then acts upon. The initiative, the direction, and the follow-through all flow from Leo. Anatolius’s role in this sequence — informant to Rome — is the structural reality beneath the collegial language of “my brother and fellow-bishop.”

Leo’s consistent framing of the emperor’s obligations as obligations to the “universal Church” deserves attention across this cluster. In Letter CXLV he presented his supplication as made on behalf of the universal Church; here he describes the emperor’s confidence as shown “toward the universal Church.” The repetition is not rhetorical padding — it reflects the consistent jurisdictional claim that Leo’s office encompasses the whole Church, and that when he addresses the emperor he does so as the holder of that universal responsibility. The emperor is not dealing with the bishop of one important see; he is dealing with the one through whom the universal Church presents its cause and defines its standard. This is the ordinary and immediate jurisdiction of the Roman pontiff visible in its most natural register: not announced as a claim, but assumed as the operating premise of every sentence.

The closing of Chapter II states with uncommon directness the proper division of roles between the Roman See and the imperial office. Leo defines what must be maintained — the Chalcedonian settlement, the conditions of legitimate episcopal standing, the boundaries of orthodox communion — and imperial power enforces it. The stubborn opposition of heretics “immediately subsides when restrained by imperial power.” The restraint follows from the definition; the definition is not itself subject to imperial revision. This is the same structure that was made legally explicit in 445: Leo’s judicial determination preceded and governed the imperial rescript (Letter VIII, June 19) and the Novella (July 6) that followed. The principle stated here in general terms had been enacted in law twelve years earlier. Leo is not proposing a new arrangement — he is describing the one already in place.

The Early Church and Peter's Primacy